Former NAU Fraternity Leader Sentenced for Felony Hazing in Pledge’s Death

Lafayette, IN, October 1, 2026 — In Flagstaff, Arizona, a former leader within a Northern Arizona University fraternity has been sentenced in connection with the death of an 18-year-old pledge. Carter Eslick, who was identified as a former fraternity leader, received a sentence of 60 days in jail and will be subject to three years of probation.

Eslick pleaded guilty to a charge of felony hazing. This plea is directly linked to the death of Colin Martinez, an 18-year-old pledge. Martinez died from alcohol poisoning. The fatal incident occurred during a fraternity event.

The legal proceedings have concluded with this sentencing, marking a significant development in the case. The felony hazing charge signifies the severity of the offense and its direct consequence on the pledge’s life. The details surrounding the fraternity event where the alcohol poisoning occurred were central to the investigation and subsequent legal actions.

Felony hazing charges, such as the one Eslick pleaded guilty to, can carry substantial penalties, reflecting the dangers associated with such initiation practices. The outcome underscores the legal ramifications for individuals involved in organizing or permitting activities that lead to severe harm or fatalities. The sentence of jail time and probation aims to address accountability and serve as a deterrent.

The death of Colin Martinez brought attention to the practices within collegiate Greek life and the responsibilities of fraternity leaders. The case in Flagstaff serves as a stark reminder of the potential dangers inherent in hazing rituals and excessive alcohol consumption at fraternity-related gatherings.

Story summarized from the original created by KPHO News staff, Gray News staff, Associated Press on www.wlfi.com, see more information here.

Media gallery